Two average players on the wrong side of 30... who'd both start for them

The prospect is definitely the key piece. But they’d probably want more value than just two average players on the wrong side of 30

Don't know what formula they're using but it says I'd be giving up 10 "points" more than I'm getting in return, mostly due to the prospect

Yep. That's why I went looking for something else to use. There's that trade calculator on OS

Wow baseball trade values is by subscription only now. Thats wild

It’s not perfect, but baseball trade values gives Tatis a value of 191. O’Neil is at 8, Montas probably not much higher

You prob right. Ah well. Would've fit my team strategy perfectly (and fixed the mistake of trading him for James Shields)

and likely wasn’t going to re-sign

Soto also wasn’t locked up long term

King is coming off an all-star year and is younger than Montas

They also traded for Jung Hoo Lee so add another massive contract into their budget

I just feel like that would be an organization in desperation mode

They traded Soto for Michael King and Drew Thorpe (and then traded Thorpe for Cease so essentially just King)

I think you’re overvaluing O’Neil and Montas

For a 27 year old who’s probably a top 5 OF in the league?

Yeah

O’Neil is 30?

Yeah

Montas is what? 33 at that point?

Unless I trade for their worst prospect to add more

I mean, I'm limited by the game only allowing you to add 3 players

the context is there, but the return isn’t

And gives them $35M ish to work with heading into the next season

No way

I can kick them Montas, who would become their second best pitcher, Tyler O'Neill for a quality OF on a much cheaper contract and an A pitching prospect. I think that's a pretty good haul

With Machado, Bogaerts and Tatis, Jr's massive contracts

But they can't improve because they're in budget hell

They have four 75 overall starting pitchers in their rotation. They ain't winning with that

They are in the same division with the Dodgers and the reigning World Series champs Diamondbacks

It makes sense in my head

Hear me out first

The Padres took some pretty big Ls in free agency, losing Cease, etc.

lol

For Tatis, Jr

So I'm in the '25 offseason in my chise and I'm debating a trade