Jordan McAlary and Hawaii's Surprise Run
A quarterback searching for one more chance. A coach learning how to love football again. Together, they helped write one of the most unexpected stories of the 2021 season.
By
Stewart Mandel
At this time a year ago, Porter Davis wasn't sure he would ever work in football again.
At this time a year ago, Jordan McAlary wasn't sure he would ever play football again.
The former Arkansas head coach had spent much of 2019 and 2020 focused on something far more important than game plans, recruiting battles, or championship aspirations. After stepping away from coaching following a serious health scare and eventually resigning amid continued uncertainty surrounding his recovery, Davis was learning how to live a life that didn't revolve around football.
For the first time since he was a young assistant, there were no practices to run. No recruiting visits to make. No midnight film sessions. No pressure.
And, perhaps surprisingly, he was okay with that.
So when Hawaii first reached out during the 2020 season about a potential consulting role, Davis politely declined.
"I just wasn't ready," he would later admit.
The idea intrigued him, but the timing didn't feel right. His focus remained on his health, his recovery, and his family. Football could wait.
When Hawaii called again after the season, however, the conversation felt different.
The position came with no clearly defined responsibilities. There would be no recruiting territory to manage. No meetings he absolutely had to attend. No expectation that he would work eighty-hour weeks. It was simply an opportunity to contribute when he felt able and step away when he didn't.
Most importantly, it gave him a chance to dip his toe back into football rather than dive headfirst into it.
In January, Davis quietly accepted a one-year consulting agreement with the Rainbow Warriors.
Neither side viewed it as a long-term commitment. The contract was intentionally simple. Hawaii could move on if it felt the arrangement wasn't working. Davis could walk away if he discovered football no longer belonged in his life.
There would be no hard feelings either way.
As it turned out, the arrangement may have been exactly what both sides needed.
One of the people most responsible for making it happen was Hawaii assistant Trent Figg. After serving as the program's chief of staff in 2020, Figg transitioned into a defensive assistant role for the 2021 season. He and Davis had crossed paths numerous times throughout their careers and had developed a friendship built on mutual respect.
When discussions about bringing Davis aboard began, Figg became one of the strongest advocates for the move.
It didn't take long for Davis' influence to become noticeable.
Officially, he remained only a consultant. Unofficially, players and coaches routinely referenced his impact throughout the season. He helped evaluate defensive concepts, contributed ideas during game-planning discussions, introduced practice drills he had used successfully throughout his career, and occasionally assisted with recruiting efforts.
One recruiting battle in particular carried special significance.
Jordan McAlary.
Years earlier, McAlary had been the quarterback of Davis' final Louisiana team. Together they had helped usher in a new offensive identity for the Cajuns, with McAlary throwing for a school-record 4,414 yards and 28 touchdowns during the 2017 season. It appeared to be the beginning of something special.
Instead, injuries derailed nearly everything that followed.
A broken wrist limited McAlary to just two games in 2018. Another injury ended his 2019 season after only three appearances. Then came the COVID season, which McAlary elected to sit out entirely.
By the time he entered the transfer portal as a graduate transfer, many around college football viewed him as a talented player whose best days were likely behind him.
Davis disagreed.
According to several people inside the program, Davis became heavily involved in recruiting McAlary to Honolulu. He understood exactly what kind of player Hawaii was getting. More importantly, he understood exactly what kind of person they were getting.
For McAlary, the opportunity to reunite with a coach he trusted was equally appealing.
Neither man knew it at the time, but the partnership that had briefly flourished in Louisiana was about to receive a second chance.
Preseason expectations for Hawaii were modest. The Rainbow Warriors were largely viewed as a middle-of-the-pack Mountain West team entering the year. Most projections placed them behind programs such as Fresno State, Nevada, San Diego State, and Utah State.
By midseason, those predictions were beginning to look outdated.
McAlary quickly emerged as one of the conference's most productive quarterbacks, displaying the confidence and aggressiveness that had once made him one of the nation's most exciting passers. Hawaii opened conference play with a dramatic win over nationally ranked Fresno State before adding victories over San Jose State, Utah State, UNLV, Colorado State, and Wyoming.
The defining moment of the season came in early November when undefeated San Diego State arrived in Honolulu.
The game effectively served as a de facto division championship.
What followed became an instant Mountain West classic.
McAlary threw for more than 400 yards as Hawaii and San Diego State traded touchdowns deep into the fourth quarter. Every time one team appeared ready to seize control, the other answered. When the final whistle sounded, Hawaii had escaped with a thrilling 45-41 victory that ultimately secured the conference championship game berth thanks to the head-to-head tiebreaker.
Suddenly, one of the country's most surprising seasons had become very real.
The Rainbow Warriors finished the regular season 10-3 and 7-1 in conference play, earning a trip to the Mountain West Championship Game against Utah State.
The title game itself felt like a fitting conclusion to Hawaii's remarkable run.
McAlary threw for more than 350 yards and rallied the Rainbow Warriors from a second-half deficit, but Utah State answered with a late scoring drive before making one final defensive stand. Hawaii's dream season ended with a narrow 34-31 loss.
The disappointment lingered only briefly.
Several weeks later, Hawaii returned home to face Memphis in the Hawaii Bowl.
For four quarters the game resembled the entire season: explosive offense, momentum swings, and plenty of drama. Trailing 35-31 late in the fourth quarter, Hawaii placed the ball in the hands of the quarterback who had carried them all year.
McAlary delivered.
With less than a minute remaining, he engineered a game-winning touchdown drive, throwing the decisive score that gave Hawaii a thrilling 38-35 victory and its eleventh win of the season.
As the celebration erupted around him, McAlary made his way toward midfield.
Waiting there was Porter Davis.
The embrace between the two men lasted several seconds.
Neither seemed particularly interested in letting go.
For McAlary, it represented the culmination of a journey that had nearly been stolen by injuries and bad luck. For Davis, it represented something entirely different.
Proof.
Proof that football could still be part of his life without consuming it.
Proof that he could contribute without sacrificing his health.
Proof that he still loved the game.
In the aftermath of the bowl victory, Davis was asked the question everyone in college football seemed to be wondering.
Would he return to Hawaii in 2022?
Would he consider taking on a larger coaching role somewhere?
For perhaps the tenth time that evening, Davis smiled.
"I honestly don't know," he said. "I need to take some time, talk with Maya, and figure out what makes sense for us."
It was not the definitive answer many were hoping for.
But unlike a year earlier, it wasn't a dismissal either.
For now, that was enough.
A year ago Porter Davis was trying to figure out whether football still had a place in his life.
Today, after one of the most surprising seasons in college football, the question no longer seemed to be whether he would return.
The question had become what that return might look like.